Fundsindia.com | Invest Online in India

Marketplace - FundsIndia

Official blog of FundsIndia.com

Five Myths about SIP Investing

Systematic Investment Plan (SIP) is now a word that has caught on in the investing world. And the idea of investing small sums has appealed to most of you, no doubt. But equally, there are many misconceived notions on what SIP is all about and how it needs to be used. Here are a few myths about SIP that we would like to demolish, so that you may use SIPs more effectively and build wealth optimally.

Myth 1: SIP is only for the short term

It is the most common myth about SIP investing, especially when it comes to SIPs in equity funds. Many of us are willing to commit regular sums for investing in PPF and insurance policies, or for repaying the housing loan. But we are quite cynical about committing a regular sum in a mutual fund SIP, especially in equities. Many of us consider equity investments for short term and debt investments for long term.

In reality, it should be vice versa. Why? Simple – debt products generate good returns for you only in favourable or high interest rate cycles. However, equities generate returns when they traverse across up and down market cycles – providing you opportunities to buy cheaper in down cycles and generate wealth in up cycles. SIPs, by their very nature, help you navigate these market cycles by averaging costs.

In the short term, SIP equity returns may be negative due to temporary market corrections. But that is when your SIP is actually doing the job of cost averaging. By interrupting it, you do not allow it to work well for you. Hence, make sure you run your SIP for the long term – across at least one down market cycle and up cycle to take advantage of the market volatility.

Myth 2: SIP is for small investments

SIP means investing small sums. Hence, SIP is for the ‘small investor’ is the notion about SIPs. Even recurring deposits in banks allow you to invest small sums. Does that make it an ‘aam aadmi’ product?

SIP is meant to be a vehicle for disciplined, regular, long-term investment on an auto pilot mode. It is meant to average rupee costs and provide an opportunity for all – those with limited as well as high savings – to participate in smart investment options.

Whether you invest Rs 1,000 a month or Rs 10,000 a month, rupee cost averaging works alike for all. You buy through ups and downs using an SIP, whether you are a small retail investor or a High Net-worth Individual (HNI).

Many HNIs in fact, are known to prefer the SIP route compared with lump sum investments. Whether it is a small or big sum, by investing regularly, you will reap the benefits of SIPs in the long term.

Myth 3: My SIP returns on an absolute basis is low

Many investors look at the absolute returns on their SIP investment. They ignore the IRR (Internal Rate of Return) of their investments. Generally, in a short term SIP, the absolute return tends to look lower than the IRR or Compounded Annualised Growth Rate (CAGR) returns.

For instance, let us assume, you have invested monthly Rs 1,000 in an equity fund for 36 months. At the end of 36 months, you have redeemed Rs 45,000 from your investment. Your absolute return on your investment is 25% ((45000-36000)/36000).

However, if you calculate the IRR using an Excel sheet, you will find it has generated about 14% IRR (annualised yield) for the last 3 years.

Why is IRR a better way of looking at your return, especially when you are comparing it across other asset class yields? Because in an SIP, you do not make all your investments at one go. You invest at various points in time. Hence, there is no one point-to-point annualised return. The returns, taking into account the varying times of investment is better captured using IRR.

Myth 4: I can time the market better

Well, perhaps you can. But can you do that every time? Moreover, if many people could do that, then there would not be many market opportunities in the first place. Besides, there are so many extraneous factors that always belie even the top investment gurus.
Due to multiple known and unknown factors, market fluctuates at various levels and exhibiting volatility. These market fluctuations are harder to predict by most of the investors. It is the time in the market that matters, not timing the market. Hence, if you come to terms that you cannot always time the market, you would simply run an SIP and allow your SIP to time your investments well for you. And that too, even while on an auto-pilot mode! Of course, nothing prevents you from adding to these SIPs with occasional lump sums.

Myth 5: I should not start/continue SIPs at high market levels

Many of you may be hesitant of starting an SIP after markets run up a bit – as is the case now. Some of you may even want to stop your SIPs because you do not want your SIPs to be buying units at ‘higher’ NAVs.

If SIPs were all about the need to do away with timing the market, why would you worry again about the timing?

SIPs have nothing to do with ‘when you start?’ It is all about ‘how much time’ you have.

If you have time on your side, you can start your SIP at any market level. After all, by starting your SIP, you are only investing one instalment of your long term SIP. You would not know the market behaviour during the rest of the tenure of your instalments. Markets may trend higher or lower over the course of your SIP.

If you did not make a start and markets moved higher, that simply means you did not take up the chance to invest at lower levels, isn’t it? Hence, ignore the market levels and stay invested for a longer term to reap the benefits of averaging.

There are many more myths on the misunderstood ideas about SIPs that keep away investors from this smart investment mode. More myth busters will follow in a future article.

Until then, happy festivities! Make a bright beginning with an SIP now!

Get FundsIndia's articles delivered straight to your inbox!

Enter your email address to get:
  • Mutual fund recommendations from experts
  • Buy, hold or sell calls for stocks
  • Investment tips and tricks
  • All the latest news from FundsIndia.com

Facebook Comments

,

6 Responses to Five Myths about SIP Investing

  1. Satish October 20, 2014 at 1:22 pm #

    Hi

    Its a good article about SIPs. I have few question on the above article. What is Annualised return and CAGR? In judging the performace of the fund for the long term which return we need to consider XIRR, Annualised return or CAGR? Please clarify

    • Sathyamoorthy N
      Sathyamoorthy N October 23, 2014 at 10:22 am #

      Hi Satish

      Please find below the clarifications on various returns.

      Annualised Return.
      If you are generating 1% return on your investment for 1 month. If you annualise this 1% for 12 months, then you will get 12% simple annualised return
      CAGR and IRR
      CAGR, IRR & XIRR all are same.
      CAGR is applicable for single lump sum investment.
      IRR is applicable for SIP investments made on same dates (regular intervals) in a month.
      XIRR is used to calculate the returns on the SIP or lump sum Investments that made on irregular intervals (Any dates).This formula can be used only in excel sheet to calculate complicated calculations (multiple investments and multiple withdrawals over a long period).
      CAGR is highlighted in many mutual fund websites and rating sites. Hence, CAGR is the better tool to judge the performance of the fund. If you want to know the SIP past performance of a particular fund, some mutual fund sites highlight the return on the SIP over the last few years. They use IRR/XIRR to calculate the returns.

    • Ajay November 12, 2014 at 7:31 am #

      Hi Satish

      I think the article is about myths about SIP.

      The author should add the 6th myth about CAGR, XIRR or annualized return.

      The gist of the article is start investing and start it for long term.

  2. Ranga October 23, 2014 at 9:09 pm #

    Thanks for this one. A well-explained article.

  3. Sundar August 2, 2016 at 4:34 pm #

    Hi,

    I dont get this IRR / XIRR calculation logic at all.

    I couldn’t find a satisfactory answer elsewhere.

    Take my investment example: I have a SIP of Rs.3000/month from 1st June 2015 to 1st June 2016 amounting to total investment of 39,000 always done on the first working day of every month in a MF.

    Now the current value of this investment on 1st June 2016 is 40,498. Which is (40,498-30,000)/30,000 * 100 = 3.84 % – Absolute return. So 39,000 outflow of cash from me over a period of 13 stand at 40,498.

    But when i use XIRR for this scenario, i get the value as 15.61% where i was forced to provide a ‘guess’ in excel sheet formula and i gave it as 0.1.

    Could you please explain what exactly is the return on my investment ?

Leave a Reply

Hello Budy! plugin is activated, now you need to set option from Settings -> Sticky Header/Footer menu